27 May
2004

American Idol

It is now safe to venture back to the television on Tuesday nights! American Idol has finally wrapped up its season and selected a "winner." I must admit I have only seen about 25 minutes of this show, immediately thereafter I found the sharpest, rustiest object nearby, and proceeded to gouge out my eardrums. Thankfully, the ensuing surgery rendered me deaf for the duration of the show. If only we could render the contestants mute.

I do find the American Idol voting controversy provides a telling glimpse into the minds of the American public. For those of you who are in blissful ignorance, the three supposedly most talented contestants were black females. Despite their alleged superiority they consistently ended up receiving the fewest votes, which are cast by viewers via phone or text messaging. When glaringly less talented non-black contestants kept receiving more votes cries of racism echoed throughout the press, even prompting Elton John to call the process clearly racist.

Meanwhile, the United States Senate does not have a single black Senator. It's 97% white, with one Native American and two Hawaiins. Funny how there is no outrage or press coverage here. When was the last time you saw a major news source focusing on archaic laws striking felons from the voting rolls, even long after they've served their time, or how about the last story you saw focusing on the many attempts by state police and others to intimidate black voters (especially in the Deep South) from showing up at the polls on election day? My guess is not as recently as you've seen in depth analysis over the merits of American Idol's voting system.

It's too bad we'll never be able to get voters to care as much about those running their country as they do about moderately talented teenagers who can belt out sappy songs.


Posted by scott at 10:18 | Comments (5)
Re: American Idol

Just count me in your "AMEN Chorus" ....if there was some press coverage on the three minorty US Senators maybe Americans could name them as fast as they voted for Fantasia and Diana.

So I have watched a few episodes??? The voting process attracted me too. Plus, it helped that one of the contestants is from NC.

Posted by: Abby at May 27,2004 21:22
Re: American Idol

Well of course I'm singin' in that AMEN chorus with Abby. Very well said, Scott. Forgive me for straying from the American Idol topic for a second, but I'd LOVE to hear more of your law-guy thoughts about that archaic law you mentioned that keeps felons from voting. This has always bothered me - if I'm understanding it correctly, a convicted felon may NEVER again vote even after he/she has completed his/her sentence? How can this be? Do these laws vary by state? Perhaps you could devote a future posting to this? It also touches on the controversy surrounding convicted sex-offenders having to register as such AFTER they've served their sentences. Scarlet Letter-ish? or justified?

Posted by: Kristin at May 28,2004 07:25
Re: American Idol

Ask and ye shall receive. I'll devote an entire post to that in the very near future!!

Posted by: Scott at May 28,2004 08:34
Re: American Idol

You really need to be excellent to survive in this big world of online information. But with a lot of great ideas you
really have a chance. Only the best survive. Never forget that!

Posted by: Andy G. at December 28,2004 07:46
Re: American Idol

Great site, well done. I enjoy beeing here and iŽll come back soon. You do a great job. Many greetings.

Posted by: Debby Joan at April 28,2005 03:37
Post a comment










Prevent spam - use this code to post